Donoghue v Stevenson

Textual versions of document images

Donoghue v Stevenson – Appeal Papers – Appendix (Opinions)

Appendix Page 25

View an image of the original document

25

(4) LORD ANDERSON.

    My Lords, in my opinion this case is indistinguishable in its facts from the case of Mullen. Mr Milligan submitted some arguments based upon a consideration of the same cases as were urged in the case of Mullen, but I see no reason to alter the opinion I expressed in Mullen, and I refer to what I said in that case, for the reasons which compel me to differ from the views expressed by the Lord Ordinary. I agree that the Lord Ordinary's Interlocutor must be recalled.

Appendix

OPINIONS

Lord Anderson

Appendix Page 25